Wednesday, March 23, 2016

RESPECT


You may have played fair last night, but you didn't play smart. There's lots of talk about how Hillary Clinton will need Bernie Sanders supporters in the fall so she should be careful not to alienate them. It does not seem to have occurred to Sanders supporters that if he wins the nomination, the reverse will be true - perhaps more so - for him. Last night was your chance and you blew it.

I'll give you that the physical layout wasn't helpful in clarifying that we are all one party. Sitting on opposite sides of the gym made it feel like a football pep rally and you responded in kind. Running up and down the sidelines prompting the wave, cheers and foot stomping before we began was a nice display of electoral enthusiasm (that is what it was, right?), but not once, then or later, did any Sanders backer cheer our party, our unity.

And once the caucus started, it was clear you were there to demonstrate not caucus. You see, a caucus rather than a more traditional primary vote, is used when a party actually wants to achieve unity. Note I did not say consensus. Yes, we vote and the Sanders turnout was overwhelming and clear from the beginning. But the whole point of a caucus is to discuss the candidates and for each to try and persuade the other that they have the better candidate. At the very least to educate. Vote Blue, No Matter Who is more than a slogan. And if we can't talk to and persuade each other, how the hell are we going to win an election that depends entirely on persuading less involved and less sympathetic voters?

Those who spoke for Sanders did not even turn in our direction, used pep rally speech rather than persuasion and never recognized that the goal was to bring us together in common cause. Pumping up the already committed is for Sanders rallies, caucuses have a very different goal. No Sanders speaker indicated they would be behind whichever candidate won the nomination.

As a Clinton supporter, I did not expect to win the vote last night. But I did expect to be respected. When our speakers turn came they faced hoots, hollers, boos and derision. It felt like a Trump rally.

If you are a Sanders supporter who was present last night, why should you care? You "won". Here's why. While I may not believe you will get the nomination, you clearly believe so. And if that happened, you need us. The caucus was your chance to show us how we would be treated in a Sanders campaign; to persuade us that he was worth not just our vote, but our efforts. Because here is the dirty little secret of political campaigns...they are damned hard work and take every one's top effort.

You know the 300 of you last night? In order to win in November, EACH of you will need to contact, persuade, convince and convert about 30 more people. At least. Not just friends, not those who are already on board. They don't count in your total. Once the Convention is over in July you will give up your summer and fall, you holidays and weekends, your sports, your family outings and you will work. Unglamorous work this is; a phone to your ear, door-to-door, begging for money and votes, early mornings and late nights, side by side with those who may have initially backed a different candidate. And then you will have to do it all over again on election day to get each of those voters to the polls. For the many of you who caucused with us because you are in school here, but do not actually live here...will you be back to help not just the top of the ticket, but all those local candidates you barely acknowledged last night?

I've spent the better part of the last month promoting the Vote Blue No Matter Who movement. In nearly fifty years of campaigns, caucuses and conventions, I've always understood that in the end we needed to be united behind whichever candidate prevailed; to work willingly and unceasingly on their behalf in the election. But I left the caucus last night feeling terribly disrespected and in doubt about how I could possibly vote for Bernie. Enthusiasm cannot substitute for respect for the process and the other participants.






2 comments:

michelemaines said...

Some random thoughts after reading this and also after our Boise caucus.
I think that many, many of the participants had/still have no idea how a caucus is meant to work, and went honestly thinking "rally for (whichever candidate) and acted accordingly.
The separate sides didn't help us out either; ours was the opposite sides of the huge century link arena with the mostly empty undecided section on the floor between us, there was no talking between the sides going on.
It was so late by the time we got started that most of us did only the first vote as we were going in. That vote count did not get finished and announced until after we and the vast majority of attendees had left - I think the newspaper said at 11:30? So most people left knowing that they wouldn't change their vote anyway, but there wasn't even any discussion of the possibility.
Our speeches, especially Mayor Bieter's, seemed like just a formality. I actually thought that Bieter did a good job of keeping his tone light, and also talking about backing whoever the final candidate turns out to be, as well as remembering local candidates when it comes time to vote. I think that both he and the MC, Lauren McLean's handling of the Sanders crowd's enthusiasm kept the rally...oops, caucus, from getting nasty.
Finally, the Hillary side was decidedly, well, older. And alot of the Bernie folks were younger, yes, but also somewhat of a hipster crowd. Watching them I suddenly had this realization of how very cool and trendy it is to "feel the bern". Then I wondered if that many of his followers have a complete understanding of the two candidates as well as how they would fare as president. Or maybe I am just a crabby older Hillary supporter. 😕

Marcia Banta said...


The majority of our Bernie supporters were college kids (many not local) and registering to vote for the first time. That should be good right? Unfortunately, they said they were there because once Bernie was elected in November they would not have to pay for college anymore. Guess they have not yet learned about the legislative branch and the federal budgeting process. Narrow self-interest without realistic thought out strategy...just like Bernie.